Contact Information

Have you stayed with us before?

Reservation Information


Reservation Credit Cards

This is a SECURE server! - Optional, please provide CC Info here!

Enter your credit card information to guarantee this reservation. A reservation cannot be guaranteed without providing a credit card but your credit card will not be charged until you arrive. Or, if you would rather wait to find out room availability before giving your credit card number or would rather call us with the number, you may do so at (317)635-9123. We will get back to you within 24 hours of your request.

Name On Card

Gary Hofmeister

Innkeeper / Owner

Reviews & Praise for Old Northside

  • Two Finnish girls could not have found a cooler place to stay on their cross country trip. Thank you for the unforgettable experience and the amazing breakfast.

    - Julia & Sonja

  • Thank you for a wonderful stay. We plan on coming back whenever in Indy. You made us feel at home and we plan to spread the word to anyone coming this way.

    - Tom & Marcy Reto

  • Thank you so much for everything. What a wonderful anniversary. And you make the best oatmeal cookies ever! We hope to be back very soon!

    - John & Natalie Harris

  • Thank you so much for helping us have such a great weekend and make memories to hold us through the upcoming year apart. We will never forget this.

    - Daniel & Kristy Hall

  • This is the nicest B&B I’ve been to! We loved the beautiful old building, the hospitality and the comfort. Thanks for a great home base for our first visit to Indiana!

    - Emilio & Elena Santini

  • Gary, Thank you for the awesome hospitality and stimulating conversation. This was the “perfect venue” and “great escape from the maddening crowd.” Best!

    - Tracy & Sharon Miller